Celebrating Job Losses

We got the bounce I was calling for last week from our technically oversold condition and the extreme bearish sentiment we had then. Early in the week, the markets held support at 1040 and then proceeded to rally fast, for a weekly gain of around 3.7%. Not bad, but the up week was a reversal from the three prior down weeks. We completed the worst August in nine years this past week and we are heading into the seasonally most difficult time of the year for the markets.

It appears that the wild swings are continuing as the markets are churning mostly sideways for the last few months. Another observation is that the markets are trading at the same levels as they were 11 months ago. The markets are forming a base. It is yet to be determined which way we break out from that base. It really comes down to a question of how much faith do you have in the economic recovery?

On Friday it was announced that the labor force lost 54,000 jobs in August. That was much better than the expected 105,000 job losses; therefore market participants celebrated and drove the market up on this news. Apparently, less bad means good for many investors. Government jobs are jobs too. If they offset private sector jobs, more real people are lining up in the unemployment line. It appears that investors ignored these facts on Friday as bulls were supercharged after this economic release. While the market currently loves the job report, at some point we must realize that the economy needs more jobs, not just a slower pace of losses.

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) reported that the number of banks on the FDIC's problem list jumped from 775 in the first quarter of 2010 to 829 as of Friday. So far this year, 118 banks have failed. A total of 140 banks failed in 2009, so we are on pace to surpass that number by a wide margin. It is said that money makes the world go ‘round. When more banks are closing, the troubled list is growing, and lending is declining, what does that do to the global economy? I’m just asking.

While the markets rallied four days in a row, the volume has been decreasing with each passing day. Just like the sellers recently reached an exhaustion point – buyers may be quickly getting tired as well. There is significant overhead resistance at 1132 on the S&P 500, and 2342 on the NASDAQ. Other technical factors are quickly coming into play; such as the major downtrend line from the April highs and the 200 day moving averages. This should, very soon, also impede the market’s advance.

I have a few metal positions and a large cache of cash waiting for the market to work its way through this, the latest version of push and pull. The markets will have to break above the above mentioned resistance levels before I turn bullish in any significant fashion. I am aware of the second year Presidential cycle theory, where there have been significant rallies from the lows of the fall in year two of a President's term, to the highs the following year. Therefore I believe that if this market is going to have a momentous decline – it will occur in the next six to eight weeks.

For now I will stick with the belief that Friday's action was just another oversold rally in the context of a falling market. I would love for the economy to right itself. Nothing would make me happier than to have the housing market gain real strength. If we could attain consistent job creation, above 150,000 jobs per month (to keep up with the population growth of the US workforce), and to have consumers with more money available for disposable spending, I would be ecstatic! Unfortunately I still don’t see or understand how we are going to accomplish those things in the near term.

I do see many technical indicators flashing warning signs. Fundamentally, more jobs are being lost (whatever kind they are – public or private), and we have a Fed whose leadership has diametrically opposed viewpoints on how we solve our current problems (read Messrs. Hoenig and Bullard). Until the market breaks above or below the stated resistance or support lines, we will patiently wait for the markets to signal its next major move. Until then cash is the safest investment and all celebrations should be put on hold.

Disclosure: Pacific Financial Planners recommends that you check with your own advisor before investing. Risk tolerance and time horizons are different for each individual. Pacific Financial maintains positions in GLD, SLV, JJC, SINA, and plenty of Cash.